Mars Lumograph 8B · 10B · 12B


Mars Lumograph 8B · 10B · 12B

Also, the methodical joy of shaping a seal.

The Staedtler Mars Lumograph 8B pencil has been my go-to drawing pencil for 5+ years. During a stint as a sales associate at Blick Art Materials (still the best job I’ve ever had), I was charmed by the Lumograph’s iconic cobalt blue, semi-gloss, hex barrel while stocking shelves, and soon started testing these pencils in my own work.The Mars Lumograph is a German-made pencil hewn from California incense cedar; wood that has a delightfully woodsy scent while being sharpened. The pencil is forgiving while being shaped, and an 8B has yet to splinter on me, regardless of the quality of the sharpener I’m using. The barrel end is capped with a glossy black, rounded cap, featuring attractive pearlescent silver (almost-white) lettering in a custom typeface that, to my eye, could be the love child of Handel Gothic and Hadley Pro Sans Wide Extra.
​
It’s a thoughtful detail to have the lead grade imprinted on all six sides of the barrel, especially as the Lumograph line offers one of the largest commercially available range of leads from 10H (hardest, most clay in the core) to 12B (softest, most graphite in the core). When comparing lead grades across the line, you’ll notice that the graphite core is significantly thicker in Lumograph’s softer pencils; the 12B’s core is approximately 4.5 mm thick, the 10B and 8B are approximately 3.6 mm thick, with HB through the hard end of the line at approximately 2 mm thick. I’m an artist who unabashedly adores soft pencils, and the extra-wide cores of the upper B grades are a pleasure to use when creating smooth shadows or emphasis marks in a single swipe.The 8B pencil is generally quiet on paper and makes strong dark marks under light pressure with minimal resistance. The artist’s tradeoff with softer leads is often point durability, but in my tests the 8B held a decent point for more than five minutes of near-continuous motion before I felt it needed sharpening.
​
Before this review, I hadn’t experimented with the 10B or 12B beyond a casual swipe on test paper in a stationary store; I’d been working through my stock of 8Bs and saw no reason to switch from their consistency and durability. While testing the 10B and 12B, I was surprised to find that they didn’t offer a notable difference in practice from the 8B. Their leads are strong, lines are dark, but the 10B and 12B have disappointing erasability.The Lumograph doesn’t have an on-board eraser, so I conducted these tests with both a Pentel Hi-Polymer Eraser Cap and the Harp Seal Eraser from Sun-Star. Did this test need two erasers? Probably not, but my brain needed the tactile erosion of this soft white brick into a cute teardrop seal (a little midday hug for my parietal lobe), so here we are with two sets of tests!

And then, just for fun, I set myself up for further disappointment and compared the Lumograph’s 10B to the Mitsubishi Hi-Uni’s 10B (the Hi-Uni’s darkest available grade). The Hi-Uni’s 10B was as dark as, if not slightly darker than, the Lumograph 12B, but the Hi-Uni is a better experience in motion; it requires only a hint of pressure when mark-making, whispers on the page, and has substantially better erasability.

I still appreciate and admire the Lumograph, but likely won’t go out of my way to rebuy the 10B or 12B; the 8B gives me a consistent hand feel, quality lead, and smooth sharpening. It’s an attractive, trusty pencil, and I’ll continue working through my collection of 8Bs without remorse - but when it comes time to invest in a new box of go-to pencils, well… you’ll have to wait for the next post when I review the Mitsubishi Hi-Uni 10B in greater detail.